Do The Various Mothers of Elon Musk's 14 or So Kids, Really Hate Each Other?

The tension between Ashley St. Clair, Shivon Zilis, Grimes, and other women-particularly those vocal on platforms like X-seems to stem from a mix of personal, social, and ideological factors tied to their relationships with Elon Musk and their public personas. Based on sentiment from X posts and broader context, here's the breakdown:

Ashley St. Clair: As a 26-year-old conservative influencer claiming to be the mother of Musk's 13th child (unconfirmed by Musk as of March 1, 2025), St. Clair catches flak for her MAGA-aligned views and perceived opportunism. Critics, including some conservative women like H. Pearl Davis and Bethany Mandel, mock her for "single motherhood" or chasing Musk's clout, suggesting jealousy or resentment over her proximity to power and wealth. X posts hint at her being seen as a "pick-me" type, rubbing some women the wrong way with her brash, attention-grabbing style.

Shivon Zilis: A Neuralink exec and mother of three of Musk's kids (twins Strider and Azure, plus a third child from 2024), Zilis gets heat for her low-key, pragmatic role in Musk's life. Women like Grimes have aired frustrations-Grimes once tweeted "Tell Shivon to unblock me" during a messy 2023 spat-suggesting rivalry over Musk's attention or secrecy around their overlapping pregnancies. Her "badass" competence (Grimes' own words after reconciling) and insider status might spark envy among those who see her as effortlessly winning Musk's favor without the public chaos.

Grimes: The avant-garde musician, mother to three of Musk's kids (X Æ A-Xii, Exa Dark Sideræl, Techno Mechanicus), faces criticism for her eccentric persona and rocky, on-off dynamic with Musk. Some women on X call her out for tolerating his "harem" antics or losing her edge post-breakup, while others sympathize with her public struggles-like when Musk took their son X to political events against her wishes. Her artistic vibe clashes with the more traditional or polished images of St. Clair and Zilis, fueling tribal sniping.

The common thread? Musk's sprawling family and influence amplify competition and comparison. Posts on X suggest jealousy (over his wealth, status, or affection), hurt egos (from his apparent juggling of partners), and ideological divides (St. Clair's right-wing stance versus Grimes' quirky liberalism). Some speculate overlapping pregnancies-like St. Clair and Grimes allegedly finding out about Zilis' kids after the fact-breed betrayal or bitterness. Add public scrutiny and Musk's polarizing persona, and it's a recipe for women tearing into each other, fair or not. What do you think drives it from your angle?

Shivon Zilis and Claire Boucher aka Grimes, Reportedly were friends until a falling out over both ending up in the same hospital with Musk's babies. The story of Shivon Zilis and Claire Boucher (Grimes) is a wild one, and the hospital overlap is part of it, though it's not the full picture. They were reportedly friends-Grimes even tried setting Zilis up on dates, per Walter Isaacson's 2023 Musk biography.

Things got messy when Zilis, a Neuralink exec, had twins (Strider and Azure) with Musk via IVF in November 2021, just weeks before Grimes welcomed her second kid with Musk (Exa Dark Sideræl) via surrogate in December 2021. The hospital bit comes from Isaacson's account: both women were at the same Austin facility around late 2021-Zilis with pregnancy complications, Grimes visiting her surrogate-without knowing the other was there or expecting Musk's kids. Grimes only found out about Zilis' twins when Insider broke the story in July 2022, same as the public, and she was "outraged" at being blindsided, especially since Zilis was in Musk's inner circle.

The falling out wasn't just about the hospital, though-it was more about the secrecy and overlap. Grimes later vented on X in September 2023, accusing Zilis of blocking her and Musk of keeping her from their kids, saying it "ripped my family apart." They patched things up after a "long overdue" talk, with Grimes posting she forgave Zilis, calling her a "badass" and wanting their kids to grow up together. Zilis echoed the truce, excited for playdates. So, yeah, the hospital thing happened, but it's a footnote in a bigger saga of trust, timing, and Musk's chaotic baby-making spree