Community, Diversity, Sustainability and other Overused Words

Cali Dems pass 'Stop Nick Shirley Act' to shield migrant NGOs from cameras - and it's headed straight to Newsom's desk

Post immigrant photos with the "wrong" intent, and you could face civil lawsuits, $4,000 minimum damages, attorney fees, or even criminal penalties

California's Democrat-controlled Legislature just rammed through a bill critics are calling the "Stop Nick Shirley Act" - a measure that makes it a lot riskier to film and post videos of people working at immigrant-service outfits, even when those outfits are raking in taxpayer cash and allegedly cooking the books.

Assembly Bill 2624, authored by Oakland Democrat Mia Bonta (wife of Attorney General Rob Bonta), sailed through the Senate 30-10 on Tuesday and is now on its way to Gov. Gavin Newsom after clearing the Assembly. It expands the state's "Safe at Home" address-confidentiality program - originally created for domestic-violence victims - to cover workers and volunteers at "immigration support services" providers. Post their photo or personal info online with the "wrong" intent, and you could face civil lawsuits, $4,000 minimum damages, attorney fees, or even criminal penalties.

Republican lawmakers and independent journalist Nick Shirley say the real target is citizen reporters who have been exposing empty daycares, phantom hospices, and other fraud schemes tied to migrant-serving nonprofits. Shirley's viral videos of allegedly vacant, taxpayer-funded facilities in Minnesota and California have already triggered federal probes and arrests. Democrats responded by writing a law that critics claim will let those same groups cry "harassment" and demand the cameras be turned off.

"Instead of cracking down on the fraudsters, they're inventing laws to silence the guy filming them in broad daylight," one X user summed it up - a sentiment echoed by Assemblyman Carl DeMaio, who was repeatedly blocked from speaking against the bill's free-speech problems.

Bonta's office insists the bill only stops doxxing and threats, not legitimate journalism. Snopes and Democratic senators have dismissed the "Stop Nick Shirley" nickname as right-wing hype. But opponents note the timing: the measure was introduced shortly after Shirley's exposés went viral, and it specifically protects a politically favored industry that receives massive public funding.

Newsom now has the final say. The progressive governor has signed similar privacy expansions before and rarely vetoes pure Democratic social bills that pass on party-line votes. Still, with national eyes on California's migrant spending and fraud scandals - and Shirley's cameras still rolling - a signature would hand critics fresh ammunition that the Golden State is more interested in protecting the bureaucracy than the taxpayers footing the bill.

Will Newsom ink it and tell independent journalists to look the other way? Stay tuned. In Sacramento, the only thing more predictable than Democrat majorities is their allergy to sunlight.

 
 

Reader Comments(0)

 
 
Rendered 08/20/2026 04:09